G-02 Classifying the decision context as situation A, B, and C for building and product LCA
| Aspect | G-02 Classifying the decision context as situation A, B, and C for building and product LCA | |||||||
|
Description |
The ILCD Handbook distinguishes between different decision contexts for LCA studies. This distinction is part of the goal and scope definition of an LCA study, and has major implications for further definitions of system boundaries and modelling principles, etc. According to the ILCD Handbook, situation A modelling is defined as ‘micro-level decision support’, whereas situation B is characterized as ‘meso- and macro-level strategic (policy) decision support’. Thus situation A refers primarily to product- or process-related decision support studies, whereas situation B applies to strategic decision support studies. It is important for practitioners to understand under which situation an LCA study has to be established. In addition, the differentiation of when to use situation A or situation B might be unclear in the building sector. | |||||||
|
Related study objective |
☒ stand-alone LCA | ☒ comparative assertion | ||||||
|
Related study phase |
☒ goal and scope definition |
☐ inventory analysis (LCI) |
☐ impact assessment (LCIA) |
☐ interpretation |
☐ reporting |
|||
| Relevant for |
new buildings |
existing buildings |
construction products |
screening LCA |
simplified LCA |
complete LCA |
||
|
Provisions |
Situation A (attributional LCA) should be used for individual product or building LCA studies that do not have a major influence on the background system (such as the energy supply). Situation B (consequential LCA) should be used in modelling specific cases where macroeconomic systems are significantly affected through the use and the dimension of the assessed technology. If an LCA study is believed to be related to situation B, the ILCD Handbook and LCA literature should be consulted for guidance on how to proceed. |
|||||||
|
Rules from |
|
|||||||
|
Guidance |
Most of the LCA studies published in the building sector have used the LCA approach called attributional modelling (or situation A in ILCD). This type of modelling is the most familiar to the LCA practitioner. Alternative modelling choices are available, especially consequential modelling (or situation B in ILCD). This modelling approach assesses the consequences of the introduction of a new technology or new processes by looking at the marginal effects. The questions addressed are different in these two modelling approaches.
An attributional LCA assesses the environmental impact of one quantity unit or one piece of a product. Any scaling-up of the environmental impacts of this product is linear. This means that the environmental and technical consequences (and possibly also the economic consequences) of the life cycle of the assessed system are seen not to have significant impacts on other technical systems, products, etc. This is often seen as a feasible simplification in the process of modelling parts of the real world. A consequential LCA, by contrast, assesses the environmental impacts of products or technologies with consideration of the indirect effects, i.e. by assessing the consequences of the assessed life cycle on other systems. As an example, the assessment of biofuel might include the consequences of increased pressure for the available land in tropical forests due to energy crop harvesting, or include the assessment of consequences of a shift of technologies due to the reduced availability of one rare earth. Conducting a consequential LCA may result in special requirements for LCA background data, and typically increases the options or choices within the assessed system. As a consequence, the LCA practitioner is required to make an increased number of assumptions, which may reduce the significance of a result. The European standards EN 15804 and EN 15978 do not consider consequential LCA. It may be valid for specific cases to conduct a consequential LCA, but for the most common applications of LCA in the building and construction sector an attributional LCA should be the method of choice. If a consequential LCA is conducted, the LCA practitioner needs to fully understand the related methodologies, and therefore make him or herself thoroughly familiar with the corresponding literature. 1) Guidance for the choice between attributional and consequential LCA in the building sector
The practitioner may use consequential LCA (situation B in the ILCD Handbook) for the following applications:
Situation C is unclear in the ILCD Handbook, as it is intended not to have a decision support. However, even an internal LCA study in a company always has support, such as benchmarking, or improvement potentials. Generally speaking, most of the time the LCA practitioner in the building sector will rely on situations A or B. Whereas a single product or building does not change the background system very much (situation A), this will no longer be the case when all the building sector is considered. For example, in France, where many buildings are heated by using electricity, this leads to a winter peak demand when thermal power plants are turned on, resulting in increased CO2 emissions [Peuportier 2008]. Assessing the entire building stock should relate to a situation B decision context. Under the specific goal and scope, situation B may be used for individual systems that are large enough to potentially influence the background system. 2) Guidance for studies complying with goal and scope definition according to EN 15804/EN 15978 3) Specific guidance and current limits for consequential LCA In the LCA community, there is no commonly agreed understanding on how to decide which type of decision context situation should be applied. This is especially true for medium-scale systems (e.g. a neighbourhood or a district) for which no strict recommendations are given in the ILCD Handbook. In these cases, the use of a situation A or B should be justified by providing evidence e.g. on the possible modifications on the background system. As the distinction between attributional and consequential LCA is currently a much-discussed topic, the practitioner may also be interested in referring to the recent review articles published by [Frischknecht 2010], [Earles 2011] and [Zamagni 2012]. According to [Zamagni 2012] there are still several issues to address in consequential LCA, including the selection of appropriate data, the identification of market mechanisms, and the affected processes that should be included in the system boundaries. The authors state that scenario modelling can be a useful approach in dealing with present mechanisms and future developments. Scenarios can be predictive (what will happen?), explorative (what can happen?), or normative (how can a specific target be reached?). |
|||||||
Related study objective: comparative assertion, Related study objective: stand-alone LCA, Related study phase: Goal and scope definition, Study type: Complete LCA, Study type: Screening LCA, Study type: Simplified LCA